Subscribe to daily environment news





 

Click for news Click for pictures
National Tree Day

Planet Ark Home


FEATURE - Down but not out, protesters keep WTO in sights
Mail this story to a friend | Printer friendly version

SWITZERLAND: November 9, 2001


GENEVA - Some protesters want to sink the World Trade Organisation (WTO), the flagship of international commerce. Others would settle for a sea change in policy.


Seen as a pillar of the international economic system - along with the International Monetary Fund (IMF) - the WTO has long drawn the ire of those who feel that trade rules are stacked in favour of rich and powerful states.

The views are felt as ardently as ever, but as the WTO prepares to kick off its biennial ministerial meeting in the tiny Gulf state of Qatar on Friday, its opponents say that it may be difficult this time to get them across.

After September's attacks on the United States, decision makers have retreated behind ever higher security barriers, increasing their isolation, while public opinion in the West is taking a dimmer view of even peaceful protest, they say.

"September 11 had a profound effect," said Phil Bloomer, head of advocacy at Oxfam, referring to the day on which suspected Islamic militants flew planes into the World Trade Center and the Pentagon, killing thousands.

"It is difficult to sustain criticism of U.S. trade policy without being construed as anti-U.S.," he added.

"The whole world did change after September. The anti-WTO protest movement has lost a bit of momentum," echoed Guy Taylor of Global Resistance, a London-based anti-globalisation group.

The sheer cost of getting to the Qatari capital, Doha, and the limits organisers set on numbers of those allowed to attend meant non-governmental organisations (NGOs) were always going to struggle to be present in force at the November 9-13 meeting.

And the choice of venue ensures that there will be no repeat of the "Battle of Seattle" when violent elements within anti-globalisation groups brought chaos to the streets of the U.S. city during the last WTO ministerial meeting two years ago.

Many Seattle delegates were trapped for hours in their rooms by the street clashes which forced the cancellation of the opening ceremony.

Protesters later claimed that the vehemence of the demonstrations contributed to the eventual failure of the meeting - with developing states rejecting calls by rich countries to launch a new round of negotiations to liberalise world trade.

NO TO NEW ROUND

"All big protests need a lot of local people to get involved and there are certainly not going to be any local protesters amongst the Qataris," said Taylor.

Rather than fear of protests, it is fear of possible attack by groups linked to Saudi dissident Osama bin Laden, blamed by Washington for the September outrages, that has triggered massive security precautions in Doha where many countries will be sending reduced delegations.

As in Seattle, rich countries want backing for a new round of multilateral talks to lower barriers to trade, saying it would give a shot in the arm to an ailing world economy.

Once again, NGOs with interest in the trade issue and the anti-globalisation movement are virtually unanimous in opposing a new round, at least on the terms proposed by the most developed countries.

"We believe a completely new round would be inappropriate when many developing countries are still struggling to get what they were promised from previous rounds," said Bloomer.

"First the rich states have to deliver on their promises to open up their markets," he added.

Much of the NGO criticism of the operations of the WTO finds an echo in the positions of the poorer developing countries who have long argued that they have gained too little so far from trade liberalisation.

From foot-dragging by the European Union on textile imports from developing states, to the increasing use by the United States of its laws against so-called "dumping" of cheap goods in its domestic market, the poorer states and their supporters say they are getting a raw deal.

"The tools we used in the U.S. to develop are the same policy tools that the WTO seeks to remove from the developing countries to help them develop. We need (trade) rules but the WTO has overreached itself," said Lori Wallach, director of the U.S. NGO Public Citizens' global trade wa


Story by Richard Waddington


REUTERS NEWS SERVICE

Reuters



© 2008 Reuters Limited. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of Reuters content, including by framing or similar means, is expressly prohibited without the prior written consent of Reuters.
top

 
9 NOV 2001
ENVIRONMENT
NEWS

CHINA:
China says Tibet railway on track despite climate

CHINA:
INTERVIEW - China's GMO details still in the works

EU:
FEATURE - Labelling laws leave EU in GMO quandry

GERMANY:
UPDATE - Germany questions EU biofuel proposals

GERMANY:
Germany to amend draft law on CHP power generation

KENYA:
UN urges WTO talks not to overlook environment

MEXICO:
UPDATE - Mexico frees two jailed environmentalists

MEXICO:
FEATURE - Marine turtles drawn to lay eggs on Mexican beaches

MOROCCO:
Want to save the planet? Don't fly

MOROCCO:
UPDATE - Hard bargaining at UN climate talks in Morocco

NIGERIA:
Three die in oil pipeline fire in southeast Nigeria

PHILIPPINES:
FEATURE - New strains of rice promise better health, eyesight

PHILIPPINES:
UPDATE - About 350 believed dead in Philippine storm

SWITZERLAND:
FEATURE - Down but not out, protesters keep WTO in sights

UK:
FEATURE - Persuading the wary - consumers, GMOs and mistrust

UK:
UPDATE - UK SSE in green energy plan as H1 beats forecasts

UK:
Britain imposes no-fly zones over nuke plants

UK:
UK's Recycled Waste to reverse into AIM cash shell

UK:
UPDATE - UK scientists defend animal cull, say saved lives

UK:
FEATURE - GM crop research slow to reach hungry Third World

UK:
Greens sue Britain over nuclear fuel plant

USA:
BP introduces anti-smog gasoline in Washington state

USA:
Exxon Valdez appeals ruling stuns Alaskans

USA:
FEATURE - Life extended for Cook Inlet oil and gas fields

USA:
USTR minimizes Chile trade pact environmental impact

USA:
Group says US energy bill won't benefit consumers

USA:
Guilty plea in Phoenix eco-arsonist case



previous day
today's news
next day