Subscribe to daily environment news





 

Click for news Click for pictures
National Tree Day

Planet Ark Home


UPDATE - UK scientists defend animal cull, say saved lives
Mail this story to a friend | Printer friendly version

UK: November 9, 2001


LONDON - UK scientists defended Britain's controversial mass livestock cull to combat foot-and-mouth disease thhhis week, saying the policy had saved animals' lives and would have curtailed the crisis if used sooner.


The scientists, some of whom advised the government during the eight-month epidemic, said officials had inadvertently allowed the disease's spread by delaying introduction of the cull on farms confirmed with the disease and those neighbouring them.

But the much-criticised policy, which has led to the slaughter of millions of animals, was effective when implemented, they said.

"A prompt 24-48 hour culling policy would have resulted in a significantly smaller epidemic and fewer animals culled," Dr Bryan Grenfell, a zoology expert at Cambridge University, said at a select committee meeting.

But he said the mass slaughter was more effective than vaccinating animals because the multi-strained foot-and-mouth virus was difficult to immunise against and livestock would only be protected three to seven days after the injection.

Government scientists recommended the contiguous cull in March when 25 percent of the cases to date had been confirmed.

Nearly four million animals have been killed on over 2,000 farms - figures which led environmentalists, animal rights campaigners and some farmers to criticise the government for killing animals without the disease.

Many critics called on officials to start vaccinating animals against the highly infectious livestock disease as foot-and-mouth, first uncovered in February, lingered for months after UK officials said the battle was finally being won.

But the government's chief scientific adviser, Professor David King, reiterated that the mass cull was the only option.

"I would do the same again," he said.

"I believe this disease has been brought to a stop."

Professor Roy Anderson, an epidemiologist at London's Imperial College, said the cull had saved animals' lives.

"If we hadn't continued culling foot-and-mouth disease would be pretty endemic by now," he said.


Story by Jessica Shepherd


REUTERS NEWS SERVICE

Reuters



© 2008 Reuters Limited. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of Reuters content, including by framing or similar means, is expressly prohibited without the prior written consent of Reuters.
top

 
9 NOV 2001
ENVIRONMENT
NEWS

CHINA:
China says Tibet railway on track despite climate

CHINA:
INTERVIEW - China's GMO details still in the works

EU:
FEATURE - Labelling laws leave EU in GMO quandry

GERMANY:
UPDATE - Germany questions EU biofuel proposals

GERMANY:
Germany to amend draft law on CHP power generation

KENYA:
UN urges WTO talks not to overlook environment

MEXICO:
FEATURE - Marine turtles drawn to lay eggs on Mexican beaches

MEXICO:
UPDATE - Mexico frees two jailed environmentalists

MOROCCO:
Want to save the planet? Don't fly

MOROCCO:
UPDATE - Hard bargaining at UN climate talks in Morocco

NIGERIA:
Three die in oil pipeline fire in southeast Nigeria

PHILIPPINES:
UPDATE - About 350 believed dead in Philippine storm

PHILIPPINES:
FEATURE - New strains of rice promise better health, eyesight

SWITZERLAND:
FEATURE - Down but not out, protesters keep WTO in sights

UK:
FEATURE - GM crop research slow to reach hungry Third World

UK:
UPDATE - UK SSE in green energy plan as H1 beats forecasts

UK:
Britain imposes no-fly zones over nuke plants

UK:
UK's Recycled Waste to reverse into AIM cash shell

UK:
UPDATE - UK scientists defend animal cull, say saved lives

UK:
Greens sue Britain over nuclear fuel plant

UK:
FEATURE - Persuading the wary - consumers, GMOs and mistrust

USA:
Guilty plea in Phoenix eco-arsonist case

USA:
USTR minimizes Chile trade pact environmental impact

USA:
BP introduces anti-smog gasoline in Washington state

USA:
Exxon Valdez appeals ruling stuns Alaskans

USA:
Group says US energy bill won't benefit consumers

USA:
FEATURE - Life extended for Cook Inlet oil and gas fields



previous day
today's news
next day