Subscribe to daily environment news





 

Click for news Click for pictures
National Tree Day

Planet Ark Home


Polluters to pay under EU green liability plan
Mail this story to a friend | Printer friendly version

EU: January 24, 2002


BRUSSELS - Polluting industries will be forced to clean up environmental damage, or pay the cost, under a new European Union law due to be launched in draft form yesterday.


Big smokestack industries, and firms dealing in waste management, chemicals, and genetically modified organisms would all become liable for incidents that pollute water, air or soil or harm nature, the European Commission said this week.

The Commission has estimated the annual cost of the law to industry would be around 1.5 billion euros ($1.33 billion).

"We will make the polluter pay," Environment Commissioner Margot Wallstrom told reporters, saying the proposal was one of the most important environmental measures to come out of Brussels in years.

But environmentalists, who have been campaigning for decades to get a law that guarantees flora and fauna the same protection from industrial incidents that people and property already enjoy under existing civil liability laws, slammed the plan.

A coalition of all the big green groups met Wallstrom this week to call on her not to push it through at Wednesday's weekly meeting of EU commissioners, saying it was riddled with loopholes that made it worthless.

EASY DEFENCE FOR FIRMS

"This would not prevent disasters happening and would not make people that cause those disasters pay," Roberto Ferrigno, policy director at the European Environmental Bureau (EEB) said.

The EEB, and other groups including Greenpeace and Worldwide Fund for Nature (WWF), said Wallstrom had given in to all the main demands of industry which fears the new law would leave it open to endless legal suits from green groups.

Their main concern is that if firms can prove they complied with environmental permits they could not be held liable.

The proposal would only protect nature in defined zones of special environmental interest and green groups could not bring cases against companies themselves - both fatal weaknesses in the proposal, Ferrigno said.

Wallstrom insisted the law would force companies to clean up after illegal chemical spills or environmental accidents.

Under her proposal, government authorities would compel companies to clean up environmental damage, or do the clean-up themselves and then pursue the culprits for the costs.

Notorious disasters like the 1976 Italian Seveso chemical plant explosion or the mining waste spill that ravaged Spain's Donana national park in 1998, would have been prevented or punished by the law had it been in place then, Wallstrom said.

The law would not make it compulsory for firms to insure against the increased environmental risks, but national governments would be allowed to impose this on their companies.

Financial damages would be based on the cost of restoring the environment to health. The full board of commissioners will have to decide whether there should be a ceiling on damages or whether liability should be unlimited.

"Of course (the proposal) is a compromise - there are very strong interests here," Wallstrom said. "They (industries) are displeased at the proposal so maybe we have struck the right balance."


Story by Robin Pomeroy


REUTERS NEWS SERVICE



© 2008 Reuters Limited. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of Reuters content, including by framing or similar means, is expressly prohibited without the prior written consent of Reuters.
top

 
TODAY'S
ENVIRONMENT
NEWS

AUSTRALIA:
Almost Half of Australia Untouched by Humans: Study

AUSTRALIA:
Woodside Says Aussie CO2 Plan Threatens LNG Project

AUSTRALIA:
Australia's Rudd Says Open to Negotiate Carbon Plan

BRAZIL:
Sugar Cane to Keep More Brazilian Lights Burning

CHINA:
China to Build Hydro Power Plant in Tajikistan

CZECH REPUBLIC:
CEZ to Build Biggest Onshore Wind Park in Europe

GHANA:
Poor Nations Need US$130 Bln a Year On Climate - WWF

GHANA:
Ghana Climate Talks Make Progress to Save Forests

GREECE:
"Grease to Greece" Racers Cross Europe on Cooking Oil

INDIA:
Food Riots as Indian Floods Destroy 250,000 Homes

RUSSIA:
Quake Hits Siberia, First Reports Say No Dead

SOUTH AFRICA:
SAfrica Seeks Firms to Reprocess Nuclear Fuel

SOUTH KOREA:
South Korea to Pump US$103 Bln Into Renewable Energy

UK/US:
Even "Green" Energy Needs Lower Oil Price

US:
Exxon Agrees to Pay Out 75 Pct of Valdez Damages

US:
Cut Greenhouse Gases to Save Coral Reefs - Scientists

US:
New Orleans Considers Evacuation as Gustav Looms

US:
Arctic Ice Second-Lowest Ever; Polar Bears Affected



previous day


This site developed by Frontline, and managed by Planet Ark using RPM-NT.

Site designed by Jon Dee @ Planet Ark.

Radiant