Subscribe to daily environment news





 

Click for news Click for pictures
National Tree Day

Planet Ark Home


US court upholds ruling on plutonium shipments
Mail this story to a friend | Printer friendly version

USA: August 7, 2002


WASHINGTON - A federal appeals court on Tuesday upheld a lower court ruling that cleared the way for federal shipments of weapons-grade plutonium to a nuclear facility in South Carolina, but the state's governor vowed he would take the case to the Supreme Court.


The Department of Energy welcomed the decision from the 4th Circuit Court of Appeals and underscored the administration's commitment to disposing safely of the radioactive matter, which will be transformed into fuel for commercial nuclear reactors.

"This administration is committed to ensuring America's national security and the security of the people of South Carolina are maintained by proceeding with a program to dispose of weapons grade plutonium in a safe and responsible manner," said Energy Department spokesman Joe Davis.

Davis said the United States agreed in a September 2000 treaty with Russia that each side would dispose of 34 metric tonnes of weapons-grade plutonium.

He said the June ruling by U.S. District Court cleared the way for shipments to begin to the Savannah River nuclear facility, including some six metric tonnes from the Rocky Flats nuclear facility near Denver, Colorado.

He had no immediate details on how much of the plutonium had already been shipped to the facility since June.

South Carolina Gov. Jim Hodges signed an executive order last week declaring the plutonium a threat and ordering state police to stop any vehicle attempting to carry it into South Carolina, but the court said he could not block the shipments.

Tuesday's ruling upheld that decision, but Hodges, a Democrat seeking re-election in November, vowed to take his battle to the Supreme Court.

'NUCLEAR DUMPING GROUND'

"I spent the last four years trying to end South Carolina's role as the nation's nuclear dumping ground and I don't want us to go back," Hodges said in a statement. At the Savannah River site 160 miles (260 km) southwest of Charlotte, the plutonium is to be converted into fuel for commercial nuclear reactors.

The Department of Energy is under pressure to start shipping it soon because it plans to shut down the Colorado facility by 2006 and must move the plutonium this year to stay on schedule.

South Carolina has never objected to temporarily holding such plutonium. But Hodges questioned the environmental impact and sought legal guarantees that the federal government would follow through on plans to convert the plutonium to reactor fuel, saying he feared the state would become a permanent dumping ground for nuclear waste.

In its ruling on Tuesday, the three-judge appeals court panel said it had reviewed the Energy Department's actions and felt it complied with federal environmental requirements.

"We are satisfied that the DOE took a 'hard look' at the environmental consequences of its proposed course of action," the judges said, noting that the department's decision to store the plutonium there was "neither arbitrary nor capricious."

Davis said the department was proceeding with its plans. The appeals court has confirmed that we've made all the right decisions, and we're moving forward," he said. He had no comment on Hodges' decision to take the case to the Supreme Court.


Story by Andrea Shalal-Esa


REUTERS NEWS SERVICE

Reuters



© 2008 Reuters Limited. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of Reuters content, including by framing or similar means, is expressly prohibited without the prior written consent of Reuters.
top

 
TODAY'S
ENVIRONMENT
NEWS

CHINA:
Warmer Climate to Dry Up Peatlands - Study

FRANCE:
EU Car Loan Call Puts Spotlight on CO2 Costs

INTERNATIONAL:
UN Says Credit Crisis Could Enable "Green Growth"

LUXEMBOURG:
Green Alarm as EU Ministers Mull Climate Opt-Outs

MEXICO:
Hurricane Norbert Storms Mexico's Baja Peninsula

NORWAY:
Exotic Climate Study Sees Refugees in Antarctica

NORWAY:
"Lost" Deer Rediscovered in Indonesia

RUSSIA:
Quake Kills 13 in Russia's Chechnya Region

SINGAPORE:
Fixed Price Seen a Threat to Australia CO2 Scheme

SPAIN:
Two British Women Drown in Spanish Flash Flood

UK:
Nations to Slash Sulphur in Ship Emissions by 2015

US:
Venture Capital Looks to New Sources of Biofuels

US:
Climate Change May Threaten Biodiversity in Tropics

US:
Environmentalists Slam Bush 'Fox-in-Henhouse' Plan

US:
Alaska Pollock Fishery Near Collapse - Greenpeace

US:
Tropical Storm Nana Forms in Atlantic

US:
Carbon Tax Seen as Best Way to Slow Global Warming



previous day


This site developed by Frontline, and managed by Planet Ark using RPM-NT.

Site designed by Jon Dee @ Planet Ark.

Radiant