Subscribe to daily environment news





 

Click for news Click for pictures
National Tree Day

Planet Ark Home


EU under fire as Prestige tanker blame game begins
Mail this story to a friend | Printer friendly version

EU: November 21, 2002


BRUSSELS - As salvage teams worked to stem the oil slick from a wrecked tanker off the Spanish coast this week, the blame game was already in full swing, with many fingers pointing at the European Union for failing to act.


The Bahamian-flagged Prestige was damaged in storms off the northwest Galician coast last week and broke in half this week. Environmentalists say the damage could be twice as bad as the Exxon Valdez tanker disaster off Alaska in 1989.

French President Jacques Chirac slammed the "inability of those in charge, politically, nationally and particularly at European level" to prevent it.

The executive European Commission in turn said EU member states should act faster to implement tougher inspection rules without waiting for new European legislation to come into force.

The incident has left European Union authorities with some explaining to do.

After the last major tanker wreck off the EU coast - the 1999 Erika disaster which polluted 400 km (250 miles) of western French coastline - the bloc rushed through a bundle of new maritime regulations and pushed for tougher international rules.

The "Erika package" of rules included a global phase-out of single-hull tankers by 2015, toughened inspection standards at EU ports and the creation of a European maritime safety agency.

But, as most of the measures do not come into force until next July, they were powerless to stop the latest disaster involving another of the ageing single-hull vessels that the European Commission has branded "floating rust buckets".

TOO LATE

Even under the new rules, the Prestige would not have been banned before 2005. But if it was unseaworthy, that should have been discovered by regular inspections that EU ports have to make on 25 percent of the ships that visit them.

EU Transport Commissioner Loyola de Palacio wrote to all EU governments this week, urging them not to wait until July 2003 to put the new rules in place.

The Erika package, although too late to stop the oil slick disfiguring the once pristine Galician coast and putting local fishermen out of business, was a "real revolution in maritime transport", de Palacio's spokesman told reporters in Brussels.

The most important measure would ensure ports target older vessels, ones with a history of trouble and those flying suspect flags, instead of spending time inspecting sound, new ships.

While the clean-up operation goes on, the next round of blame will come when parties seek compensation, a process that will be hampered by the complex web of ownership which characterises modern shipping, environmentalists said.

"It's a Liberian tanker, registered in the Bahamas, managed in Greece and chartered by a company in Switzerland. The immediate response by everyone is to throw up their hands and deny responsibility," Greenpeace scientist David Santillo said.

Oil spill compensation is covered by international law, regulated by the London-based International Maritime Organisation, but activists want the European Union to do more.

"We want the EU to review its own measures to ensure, once implemented, they would have prevented this but they should also take the lead at the IMO and make sure global standards are improved. " said Sian Pullen, head of the environmental group WWF's marine programme.

"They could move faster and talk louder."


Story by Robin Pomeroy


REUTERS NEWS SERVICE

Reuters



© 2008 Reuters Limited. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of Reuters content, including by framing or similar means, is expressly prohibited without the prior written consent of Reuters.
top

 
TODAY'S
ENVIRONMENT
NEWS

BELGIUM:
Europeans Reject Animal Cloning For Food - Survey

BELGIUM:
EU to Urge Other States to Curb Aviation Emissions

BELGIUM:
France Says Burying CO2, EU Gas Shipments Urgent

BELGIUM/UK:
France, Britain Back Coal Plant Climate Fix

CROATIA:
Croatia Halts Tuna Fishing for Rest of the Year

FRANCE:
France to Fund Research on Eco-Friendly Cars

LUXEMBOURG:
France Eyes CO2 Opt-Outs for Some EU Industry - Draft

MEXICO:
Norbert Weakens But Still Hurricane Off Mexico Coast

SINGAPORE:
Warmer World Threatens "Happy Feet" Penguins

SPAIN:
Climate Change Could Force Millions From Homes

SPAIN:
Birds' Decline Shows Wider Damage to Nature - Study

UK:
Carbon Market is No Safe Haven Yet

UK:
Volcano in Lab May Help Predict Real Eruptions

US:
US Focus on Climate Could Ease Financial Crisis

US:
Fisheries Losing US$50 Billion a Year: World Bank



previous day


This site developed by Frontline, and managed by Planet Ark using RPM-NT.

Site designed by Jon Dee @ Planet Ark.

Radiant