Subscribe to daily environment news





 

Click for news Click for pictures
National Tree Day

Planet Ark Home


G8 members don't practise what they preach - report
Mail this story to a friend | Printer friendly version

FRANCE: May 21, 2003


PARIS - The Group of Eight world economic summits have become discredited because members preach to other countries while failing to put their own houses in order, according to a "Shadow G8" report by former top world officials.


This growing "crisis of legitimacy" undermines cooperation among the world's leading industrial democracies as challenges such as terrorism heighten the need to work together, it said.

The report by 20 experts including former U.S. Secretary of State Henry Kissinger, former Federal Reserve Chairman Paul Volcker and former European Union Commissioner Leon Brittan, came out two weeks before the June 1-3 summit in Evian, France.

The "Shadow G8" also described mounting U.S. budget deficits as alarming, saying Washington should avoid new tax cuts, and said leaders at this year's summit should help boost world trade by pledging to scrap all industrial goods tariffs in a decade.

"The widespread charge that the G8 is both undemocratic and hegemonic stems fundamentally from its asking others to do what it is unwilling or unable to do itself," said the report issued through the French Institute for International Relations (IFRI).

"The apparent unwillingness of the G8 members to criticise themselves, combined with their revealed proclivity to criticise others, has produced a crisis of legitimacy," it said.

Leaders of the 28-year-old Group - from the United States, Japan, Germany, France, Britain, Italy, Canada and Russia - meet annually to coordinate their economic and trade policies.

But "out of area issues" such as financial crises in Latin America and Asia or debt and disease in Africa have increasingly crept onto their agenda, sometimes taking centre stage as G8 policy coordination shifted to the back burner, the report said.

The "Shadow G8," which began offering recommendations to these summits three years ago, said Group members must overcome tensions caused by the war in Iraq and focus on jointly tackling the economic aspects of current security problems.

WORLD ECONOMIC PROBLEMS

Reviewing world economic problems, the report said the summit should urge the United States "to avoid any new tax cuts that are not aimed at immediate stimulus and to freeze the sizable tax cuts that are now scheduled."

Leaders should ask Europe to reform labour markets and pension systems, make the eurozone's Stability and Growth Pact more flexible and modify the European Central Bank's guidelines to aim for an inflation target of one to three percent. The ECB currently defines price stability as anything below two percent.

As for Japan, it recommended the summit urge Tokyo to write off non-performing loans in the banking system, expand reserves to the financial system, provide further short-run fiscal stimulus and deregulate the economy aggressively.

"The most dramatic step that the G8 leaders could take at Evian...would be an agreement to eliminate all of their tariffs on industrial products by a certain date (perhaps 2015 or 2020)," the report added.

It also called for more emergency oil stockpiles and said the summit should pressure Washington to take a more energetic approach to combating climate change. But it added that "It would be hopeless and counterproductive to suggest that the United States should return to the (Kyoto) protocol."


Story by Tom Heneghan


REUTERS NEWS SERVICE

Reuters



© 2008 Reuters Limited. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of Reuters content, including by framing or similar means, is expressly prohibited without the prior written consent of Reuters.
top

 
TODAY'S
ENVIRONMENT
NEWS

BELGIUM:
EU Revamps Cod Recovery Plan In Bid To Save Species

BELGIUM:
Scrapped Ships Must Be Broken Safely, EU Says

CANADA:
World's Oldest Polar Bear Dies At Canadian Zoo

CANADA:
Canada Wants North American Cap-And-Trade System

FRANCE:
Use Flower Power To Save Europe's Bees - EU Lawmaker

GUATEMALA:
Guatemala Taps Coffee Farms For Hydro Power

INDONESIA:
Indonesia To Plant 100 Million Trees This Year

MACEDONIA:
Macedonians Plant Six Million Trees In Single Day

NIGERIA:
Sea Surges Could Uproot Millions In Nigeria Megacity

PANAMA:
Strong Quake Strikes Panama, No Damage Reported

SINGAPORE:
US, Indonesia Link Up On Forest Carbon Credits

UK:
British Carbon Sale To Swell Government Revenues

UK:
UK Sells Carbon Emissions Permits In First Auction

UK:
UK Law's Passage Arouses Dispute Over Green Energy

US:
INTERVIEW -Obama Climate Pledge "Very Positive" - UN Official

US:
Mammoth Genome Sequence May Explain Extinction

US:
Politicians Persuaded To Save Canada Boreal Forest

US:
Nike, Starbucks Calling For New US Climate Policy

US:
Tiny, Long-Lost Primate Rediscovered In Indonesia

US:
Astronauts Install Water Recycler On Space Station



previous day