Subscribe to daily environment news





 

Click for news Click for pictures
National Tree Day

Planet Ark Home


Climate Change Battle Could Spell New Disasters
Mail this story to a friend | Printer friendly version

UK: June 7, 2007


LONDON - Rich countries meeting in Germany this week will agree that they need to confront climate change, but unpleasant tradeoffs are already emerging.


Unless properly managed, a rush to reshape the world's economy to arrest climate change could end up trampling the lifestyles of the rich, the livelihoods of the rural poor, and the earth's most vulnerable habitats.

A tequila shortage is perhaps one of the least-expected results of planting lucrative, "climate-friendly" biofuels -- as Mexican farmers set ablaze their fields of cactus-like agave to make way for corn, a feedstock for ethanol. Biofuels are also blamed for raising food prices and destroying forests.

The result of misguided climate policies could be to undermine public support for action and discourage businesses from buying in.

"Definitely there'll be tradeoffs between climate change and the local environment, and with energy security," said Fatih Birol, chief economist at the International Energy Agency (IEA), which advises rich countries.

"We are not in the luxury of being able to choose from hundreds of energy types."

Just how mankind plans to battle climate change is still sketchy, but one buzz word is "scaling up" -- for example by boosting research into and deployment of clean energy technologies like wind and nuclear power and biofuels.

Urgency has been spurred by a series of UN climate reports this year confirming threats like desertification, droughts and rising seas and calling for action now to cut the long-term cost.

But evidence is emerging of the repercussions. British charity Christian Aid says Colombian rebel groups are forcing poor people off their land to grow lucrative palm oil for biodiesel, likening it to diamonds financing African wars.

"You could have blood biofuels in the same way as blood diamonds. It's a classic case of exploiting natural resources behind the veil of conflict," said Christian Aid climate policy analyst Andrew Pendleton.

"Unscrupulous private sector operators, rebel groups, are keen to make a fast buck."


POOR

Biofuels already occupy an area equal to all of the arable land in France, says the IEA, and they are blamed for raising the cost of corn, sugar and other foods they compete with for land.

But negative repercussions are hard to prove.

A hike in the price of tortillas, a Mexican staple, was blamed on biofuels and sparked riots, but may have more to do with the monopoly power of dominant tortilla producers, says Annie Dufey, research associate at Britain's International Institute for Environment and Development (IIED).

Such fears risk fatalism and favour the status quo, said Bert Metz, chair of a major UN report published last month on policy options.

"Problems of land ownership and poor people are there, let's do something about it, but not blame it on climate change," he said.

"There's no basis for supposing climate policies will create more problems than they solve, provided they're put in place wisely. I'd view that as another excuse for doing nothing."

The report did not weigh the cost and benefit of the recent consumer fad of boycotting air freight and travel to reduce carbon emissions, which could inadvertantly hurt African exports and tourism.

"It's inequitable, tokenism," said the IIED's Bill Vorley of such consumer concerns.

Fresh fruit and vegetable exports from sub-Saharan Africa accounted for less than 0.1 percent of total British greenhouse gas emissions, but supported more than one million people, the IIED estimates.


SMALL IS BEAUTIFUL

On energy supply, a focus on small-scale distribution is the answer to fighting climate change and poverty both at once, say non-governmental and UN organisations.

In an interview with Reuters, Clemens Betzel, the president of Cardiff-based solar power company G24 Innovations, put on a table a bendy, solar power generator the size of a sheet of paper.

It produces enough power to run a mobile phone or light bulb, but there's plenty of demand for that, he said.

"People sit on a street corner se


Story by Gerard Wynn


REUTERS NEWS SERVICE

Reuters



© 2008 Reuters Limited. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of Reuters content, including by framing or similar means, is expressly prohibited without the prior written consent of Reuters.
top

 
TODAY'S
ENVIRONMENT
NEWS

AUSTRALIA:
Malaria and Dengue the Sting in Climate Change

AUSTRALIA:
Torrential Rains Hit Australia State, One Dead

BELGIUM:
Global Warming Could Lead To More Arctic Energy

BELGIUM/UK:
Not Promising The Earth, Ethical Banks Win Custom

GERMANY/BELGIUM:
EU Carmaking Nations in CO2 Deal as Italy Signs Up

SINGAPORE:
Aussie Miners Turn To Solar Tower Power

SPAIN:
Greenpeace Blockades Ageing Spanish Nuclear Plant

UK:
UN Publishes Draft Proposal Ahead of Climate Meet

US:
ANALYSIS - Weak Economy Could Curb Obama Coal Cleanup Plan

US:
Volkswagen Diesel Car Wins "Green Car of the Year"

US:
Automakers Detail Electric Car Plans at LA Show

US:
Wal-Mart in Wind Energy Deal with Duke Energy

US:
Broad Schwarzenegger Emissions Pledge Caps Summit

US:
Ex-EPA Official Faults Probe of BP Pipeline Spills



previous day