Subscribe to daily environment news





 

Click for news Click for pictures
National Tree Day

Planet Ark Home


US Court Dismisses False Claims Against Chevron
Mail this story to a friend | Printer friendly version

US: August 8, 2007


NEW YORK - A US court dismissed three lawsuits by Ecuadoreans who admitted allegations that pollution by Chevron Corp had caused them or their relatives' cancer were false.


The suits were part of a group of claims alleging the company's dumping in the Ecuadorean rain forest caused cancer in the communities. Several lawsuits remain under those claims.

They are unrelated to a larger litigation going on in Ecuador, which seeks $6 billion in damages from the US oil company on charges it contaminated the rain forest from 1972 to 1992. Chevron denies the claims.

Gloria Chamba, a plaintiff in the case, had alleged that Chevron pollution had given her son leukemia. But she admitted during deposition her son never had the disease.

Similarly, Luisa Gonzales said at her deposition that she had never been diagnosed with breast cancer. A related suit by her husband was also dismissed.

"In our mind, this reflects the kind and quality of allegations being made against us," said Chevron spokesman Don Campbell.

Steven Donziger, a lawyer who represents 30,000 Ecuadorean jungle dwellers suing Chevron for $6 billion, said this ruling will not affect their case in an Ecuadorean court.

"We are only suing for clean up costs, while the San Francisco case is about health impact on individuals," Donziger said. "Chevron is using their public relations spin against the thousands of legitimate Ecuadorean victims of their policies."

Judge William Alsup of the US District Court for the Northern District of California, brought up the possibility of misconduct by the plaintiff's lawyers in his ruling handed down Friday.

"It is clear to the Court that this case was manufactured by plaintiffs' counsel for reasons other than to seek a recovery on these plaintiffs' behalf," he wrote. "This litigation is likely a smaller piece of some larger scheme against defendants."

The plaintiffs' attorneys could not be immediately reached for comment.

(Reporting by Michael Erman; additional reporting by Alonso Soto in Quito)


REUTERS NEWS SERVICE

Reuters



© 2008 Reuters Limited. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of Reuters content, including by framing or similar means, is expressly prohibited without the prior written consent of Reuters.
top

 
8 AUG 2007
ENVIRONMENT
NEWS

AUSTRALIA:
Erin Brockovich Joins Down Under Refinery Fight

BULGARIA:
Seven Die in Bulgaria Floods, Romania Expects Storm

CHINA :
China City Traffic Cops Given 43 Years To Live

CHINA :
China Province Says Most Mineral Water Tainted

CHINA :
Olympics - Pollution 'Biggest Issue' Says Australian Olympic Chief

CHINA :
China Counts Cost of Wild Month of Weather

CHINA :
China Mine Flood Traps 13, Days After Rare Rescue

ETHIOPIA:
Ethiopians Fret as 'Lucy' Skeleton Heads to US

GERMANY:
E.ON Buys Windfarms in Spain, Portugal

INDIA:
INTERVIEW - India's Punj Lloyd Looking To Make Wind Turbines

INDIA:
India Drops Elephant Reserves For Mining Firms - Group

INDIA:
South Asian Flood Victims Angry at Lack of Help

JAPAN:
Radioactive Water Splashed 2 TEPCO Workers in Quake

JAPAN:
ANALYSIS - Japan Oil Firms Should Invest in Ethanol, Not ETBE

JAPAN:
Strong Quake Hits Offshore of Japan's Okinawa

NETHERLANDS:
Bluetongue Virus Spreads To More Dutch Farms

NIGERIA:
Flash Floods Kill at Least 14 in Central Nigeria

PHILIPPINES:
Philippines' Arroyo Puts Climate Change on Agenda

RUSSIA:
Russia Explorers Snub Critics in North Pole Row

SINGAPORE :
China Can Cut Emissions Without Hurting Growth - Gore

SPAIN:
Spain Hauls in 8 Tonnes of Jellyfish From Beaches

SWITZERLAND:
UN Sees Health Crisis Risk From South Asia Floods

SWITZERLAND:
Early 2007 Saw Record-Breaking Extreme Weather - UN

TAIWAN:
Taiwan Issues Sea, Land Warnings as Storm Approaches

TURKEY:
Burst Pipe Leaves Drought-Hit Turkish Capital Dry

UK:
ANALYSIS - Russia Hardens EU Resolve To Seek New Energy Supply

UK:
CHRONOLOGY - Outbreak of Foot and Mouth Disease in UK

UK:
FACTBOX - Foot and Mouth Disease

UK:
UK Says Labs "Probable" Source of Cattle Disease

UKRAINE:
French Firm Wins Tender To Build Chernobyl Shelter

US:
US Court Blocks Navy Sonar Use To Protect Whales

US:
US Court Dismisses False Claims Against Chevron

US:
New Species of Bat, Frogs Found in Congo Forests

US:
Bush Climate Meeting Draws Doubts About Action

VIETNAM:
Bird Flu Kills Vietnamese Teenager - TV Report



previous day
today's news
next day