Subscribe to daily environment news





 

Click for news Click for pictures
National Tree Day

Planet Ark Home


ANALYSIS - Nuclear Industry Eyes Oversupplied US South
Mail this story to a friend | Printer friendly version

US: February 25, 2008


HOUSTON - Would-be developers of the next round of nuclear power plants who want to build reactors in eight Southern US states are ignoring a surplus of idle generation and the region's history of nuclear cost overruns.


This week, North Carolina-based Progress Energy became the fifth company since last fall to submit a license application with the US Nuclear Regulatory Commission. Progress wants to build two reactors at a site near Raleigh which is already home to one reactor.

Of the 21 reactor sites identified in NRC filings, 15 are in the South. Four are in Texas, three in South Carolina, two each in North Carolina and Florida, and one each in Alabama, Georgia, Louisiana and Mississippi.

Unlike much of the United States, utilities in the South operate under traditional rate regulation which encourages investment in power plants and limits competition from third-party electric suppliers.

Utilities are attracted to the South for new reactors by prospects for future electric growth and by billions of dollars in federal financial incentives that are up for grabs. Because nuclear plants emit no carbon dioxide, the technology is viewed as a potential solution to rising public concern over climate change.

Nuclear-revival critics said Southeastern residents are still saddled by soaring nuclear costs from the 1980s while a glut of little-used power plants could meet future demand.


A RUSH OF NEW FILINGS

Frank Spencer, a former Mississippi assistant attorney general, has not forgotten the years-long legal battle over Entergy Corp's Grand Gulf station that pitted elected officials in Arkansas, Louisiana and Mississippi against the utility and state and federal regulators. The fight over who would pay went to the US Supreme Court.

Spencer battled unsuccessfully to keep Mississippi residents from paying more than their share of Grand Gulf's price tag which ballooned to more than $3.4 billion from $900 million.

"It was a huge burden, with the increase in rates," said Spencer, now a minister who runs a soup kitchen and shelter in Jackson. "It was the most costly plant at the time and Mississippi had to pay for one-third of it."

Today, a typical Entergy Mississippi customer still pays $12 a month for overruns at the 23-year-old nuclear plant, according to state regulatory filings.

The NRC expects a rush of new reactor filings this year from utilities seeking to qualify for nuclear production tax credits, financial risk insurance and federal loan guarantees created by the 2005 Energy Policy Act.

Georgia, Mississippi, Louisiana and Florida are among states considering more incentives to attract new reactors.

Outside of Texas, the Southeast has more than enough existing gas-fired generation to meet power needs for another decade, according to long-term forecasts from two power agencies. Utilities view these plants as unattractive because of the high and volatile cost of natural gas.

Yet few regulators have asked companies to compare the risk of future gas volatility to the uncertain expense to build the next nuclear unit even as costs soar for steel, concrete and skilled labor.

An index of power-plant construction costs showed that since 2000, the price of a new reactor has risen almost 200 percent, said Cambridge Energy Research Associates.

FPL Group's Florida utility told regulators its two-reactor expansion plan could cost from $12 billion to $16 billion, nearly double other company estimates from last year.


RATEPAYERS STUCK FOOTING THE BILL

Regulators should think carefully about burdening ratepayers with the uncertain costs of new reactors given the industry's history, said Peter Bradford, a former state utility regulator and former NRC commissioner.

"Regulators today should be looking a lot harder at a mechanism that a few states wound up using during the runaway cost era of the '80s and that's putting a cap on the amount that is recoverable from customers," Bradford said.

The Southeast is home to some of the most politically powerful utilities in the country, including Atlanta-based Southern Co, Charlotte, North Carolina-based Duke Energy, Juno Be


Story by Eileen O'Grady


REUTERS NEWS SERVICE

Reuters



© 2008 Reuters Limited. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of Reuters content, including by framing or similar means, is expressly prohibited without the prior written consent of Reuters.
top

 
25 FEB 2008
ENVIRONMENT
NEWS

ALGERIA:
INTERVIEW - Africa Must Invest To Secure Clean Water - GE

ARGENTINA:
Argentina, Bolivia, Brazil Fail To Find Gas Solution

ARGENTINA:
Argentina, Brazil to Team Up on Nuclear Power

BRAZIL:
Brazil's Lula Urges Rich To Fund Environment Reform

CHINA:
INTERVIEW - Tokyo Eyes Pioneer Emissions Trade Scheme For 2010

CHINA:
Olympics - Six China Provinces Ordered to Cut Pollution

CHINA:
China Gives Advance Farm Subsidies After Snow Damage

CHINA:
China, Japan Fail Again To Resolve Gas Dispute

CHINA:
More Snow, Blizzards to Hit Central China

CUBA:
Cuban Ethanol Boom Doubtful After Castro Exit

GERMANY:
Mining Sets Off Earthquake in West Germany

GERMANY:
ANALYSIS - Solar Sector Set To Shine Through Credit Crunch

GREECE:
Greece Faces Bleak Climate Future - EU Commissioner

INDONESIA:
Indonesia Floods Kill 11 People, Displace Thousands

INDONESIA:
Magnitude 6.6 Quake Hits Indonesia - USGS

KENYA:
Kenyan Wildlife Park Bush Fire Rages For Second Day

MONACO:
Energy Storage Nears Its Day in the Sun

MONACO:
World Fisheries Face Collapse Within Decades - UN

PHILIPPINES:
ANALYSIS - Manila Rice Plea a Wake-Up Call for a Hungry World

TAIWAN:
Tonnes of Dead Fish Wash Up on Taiwan Beaches

UK:
Amazon Nuts Help Fuel First Biofuel Airline Flight

UK:
British Government Names Climate Committee Members

US:
GM Exec Stands by Calling Global Warming a 'Crock'

US:
Is There a $500 Billion Hurricane on the Horizon?

US:
ANALYSIS - Nuclear Industry Eyes Oversupplied US South

US:
US Farmers Rush To Grains, Avoid Sugar, Cotton

US:
INTERVIEW - Pioneer Sees GMOs Gaining Global Market Acceptance

US:
Fivefold Dust Increase Chokes US West, Study Finds

US:
SUVs Race the Prius to Oscar Green Carpet

US:
Petco To Stock Fewer Pets; PETA Claims Victory

US:
Traces of Unapproved GMO Trait Found in US Corn

VIETNAM:
US "Agent Orange" Ruling Disappoints Vietnamese



previous day
today's news
next day