Subscribe to daily environment news





 

Click for news Click for pictures
National Tree Day

Planet Ark Home


Environmentalists Divided About Burying CO2
Mail this story to a friend | Printer friendly version

NORWAY: May 5, 2008


OSLO - Greenpeace and more than 100 other environmental groups denounced projects for burying industrial greenhouse gases on Monday, exposing splits in the green movement about whether such schemes can slow global warming.


Many governments and some environmental organisations such as the WWF want companies to capture heat-trapping carbon dioxide from the exhausts of power plants and factories and then entomb them in porous rocks as one way to curb climate change.

But Greenpeace issued a 44-page report about the technology entitled "False Hope".

"Carbon capture and storage is a scam. It is the ultimate coal industry pipe dream," said Emily Rochon, climate and energy campaigner at Greenpeace International and author of the report.

Greenpeace and 112 green groups from 21 nations said governments should invest in wind, solar and other renewable energies rather than in capture technologies that would allow coal-fired power plants to stay in operation.

In a statement linked to the report, Greenpeace and allies including Friends of the Earth International said the "false promise" of carbon capture and storage (CCS) "risks locking the world into an energy future that fails to save the climate".

But some other environmental groups accept carbon capture as a way to slow rising temperatures and avert more powerful storms, heatwaves, droughts, disrupted monsoon rains and raised world ocean levels.

"Carbon capture and storage is not an ideal solution, but it buys us time," said Stephan Singer, head of the WWF's European Climate and Energy Programme in Brussels. "We believe it is part of the solution -- an emergency exit."

The UN Climate Panel has said CCS could be one of the main ways for slowing climate change by 2100 -- contributing a bigger share of greenhouse gas cuts than energy efficiency, a shift to renewable energy or a push for nuclear power.


CHINA COAL

Singer said China was opening one or two coal-fired power plants a week and, with a lifetime of 40 years, the world needed ways to retrofit plants to capture emissions rather than expect Beijing to close them down.

Greenpeace said carbon capture technology was largely unproven, could not be deployed on a large scale before 2030, was expensive and brought risks of leaks. It said it would mean electricity price hikes of between 21 and 91 percent.

But Oslo-based environmental group Bellona said 34 CCS projects were being planned in Europe alone. "If you exclude CCS in the battle against climate change, you don't take global warming seriously," said Bellona head Frederic Hauge.

Several national branches of Friends of the Earth did not sign up for the statement criticising CCS.

"We believe that CCS will be an important tool to reduce emissions from existing coal and gas-fired power plants," said Lars Haltbrekken, head of Friends of the Earth Norway. "We don't support new coal-fired power plants, even with CCS."

(Editing by Janet Lawrence)


Story by Alister Doyle


REUTERS NEWS SERVICE



© 2008 Reuters Limited. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of Reuters content, including by framing or similar means, is expressly prohibited without the prior written consent of Reuters.
top

 
TODAY'S
ENVIRONMENT
NEWS

BELGIUM:
Safety of Cloned Animal Products Uncertain - EU

CANADA:
US-Canada Carbon Trading Group Eyes 2012 Start

CHILE:
Chile Says Rains Ease Electrical Rationing Fears

CHINA:
Powerful Aftershocks Hit China Quake Area, 1 Dead

FRANCE:
Too Many French Nuclear Workers Contaminated

INDIA:
India Firms Lag in Climate Action - Report

JAPAN:
Japan Firms Team Up to Develop Carbon Fibre Cars

PANAMA:
Gourmet Coffee Eats Into Panama Forest

US:
Arctic's Oil Could Meet World Demand for 3 Years

US:
Spill Closes Miss. River From New Orleans to Gulf

US:
Dolly Hits Southern Texas Cotton, Sorghum Crops

US:
Flooding Feared Along US-Mexico Border From Dolly

US:
Magnitude 6.4 Quake Near Russia's Kuril Islands



previous day


This site developed by Frontline, and managed by Planet Ark using RPM-NT.

Site designed by Jon Dee @ Planet Ark.

Radiant